Could moving temporarily into a buy-to-let property mean paying more Stamp Duty?
How we helped clients avoid an unexpected £19,500 stamp duty bill
Buying a property can be expensive enough without finding out that you might have to pay almost £20,000 more in Stamp Duty than you'd expected.
We recently helped some clients who found themselves in exactly this situation, and it's a good example of why getting specialist advice can be so important when your circumstances aren't completely straightforward.
The situation
Our clients were selling their existing main residence and purchasing a new home. However, there was a gap between selling their previous home and completing their new purchase.
Rather than renting somewhere during this period, they decided to move temporarily into a buy-to-let property they already owned. They had no intention of remaining there permanently and planned to move into their new main residence once the purchase completed.
The complication arose when their solicitor suggested that, because they owned the buy-to-let property and were living in it at the time, they would need to pay the higher rates of Stamp Duty Land Tax on their new purchase.
This would have meant a stamp duty bill of approximately £29,000, rather than the £9,500 they had originally expected. A difference of £19,500.
Why we questioned the additional Stamp Duty
Having looked at the circumstances, we weren't convinced that the higher rate should apply. Although our clients owned another property, they had already sold their previous main residence and were purchasing a new one to live in.
Our understanding was that this could qualify as replacing their main residence, even though they had temporarily lived in their buy-to-let property between the two transactions.
Under the Stamp Duty rules, replacing your main residence can mean that the higher rates don't apply, even where you continue to own another property. However, Stamp Duty is a specialist area of tax, and we're mortgage advisers rather than tax advisers. It wouldn't have been appropriate for us to tell the clients how much tax they should pay.
The problem was that the clients were being presented with a potentially much larger bill without receiving the clear confirmation they needed.
Understandably, they didn't want to pay £19,500 unnecessarily, but equally they didn't want to risk paying too little and facing a problem with HMRC later.
Getting confirmation from a Stamp Duty specialist
We referred the clients to our specialist tax partners, who were able to review their circumstances and assess how the stamp duty rules applied. Following their review, they confirmed that the purchase qualified as a replacement of the clients' main residence and that the higher rates of stamp duty did not apply.
This meant the stamp duty payable was £9,500 rather than £29,000.
More importantly, the clients had reassurance from a qualified specialist that the lower amount was correct, rather than having to make that decision themselves.
Our tax partners did not charge for the service in this instance - the solicitors suggested specialist had quoted almost £600 for the same service!
What are the rules when replacing your main residence?
Generally, if you're buying a new main residence and have sold your previous main residence within the preceding three years, you may qualify for the replacement of main residence rules.
This can mean that the additional stamp duty rates don't apply, even if you own another residential property. Temporarily living in another property between selling your previous home and buying the next one doesn't automatically prevent you from qualifying.
However, the rules depend on the full circumstances, including the properties involved, when they were sold and purchased, and whether they were genuinely occupied or intended to be occupied as a main residence.
It's therefore important to obtain appropriate tax advice where there's any uncertainty.
Why we believe mortgage advice should go beyond the mortgage
Calculating Stamp Duty isn't part of arranging a mortgage. We could simply have left the clients to resolve the issue with their solicitor.
However, when we see something that doesn't seem quite right, we believe it's important to raise the question and help our clients find the right person to answer it. In this case, that meant identifying a potential issue and arranging for a specialist to provide the reassurance they needed.
At DLi Mortgages, we try to support our clients throughout the whole buying process, not just until their mortgage offer arrives.
Whether that's dealing with lenders, communicating with estate agents and solicitors, providing detailed property information or helping clients access specialist advice, our aim is to make moving home as straightforward and stress-free as possible.
If you're planning to buy a property and would like an adviser who can support you throughout the process, please get in touch for an initial conversation.

Please note: DLi Mortgages does not provide tax advice. Stamp Duty rules can be complex, and the treatment will depend on individual circumstances. Where necessary, we can refer clients to an appropriately qualified specialist.





Comments